Let's talk

Asynchronous Instruments helps facilitators keep participants engaged with each other as they deepen their practice.

We build custom instruments for facilitators, storytellers, writers/authors, podcasters, proponents of oral learning/oracy, field workers, dream workers, retreat leaders, archivists, and masters and their apprentices.

What kind of practice do you share?

What is an asynchronous instrument?

An asynchronous instrument lets a group share a practice without being in the same place at the same time. Text messages and voice memos are already asynchronous instruments. We expand that genre by attaching recorded voices to cards, calendars, maps and stations, so they become connective tissue for a group.

Your participants practice aloud at set times, hear each other, and arrive at the next gathering having already practiced together. We build each instrument with the facilitator, around the practices they already teach.

1
2
3
4
5
The problem

What’s learned here leaves here.

The practices from a gathering are meant to travel home with participants. At yours, they learn practices from you and feel something change, and for a while the change stays with them. Then ordinary life returns, the group disbands, and each person carries the practice alone.

Keeping a practice going alone takes a great deal of energy, and coming back together takes more, whether the whole group meets again or smaller circles form. You put real work into building this community. Keeping it meeting asks for will, know-how and practice that continues, and that work is worth it, because a practice can always go deeper.

A practice field keeps what was learned in motion: practices that arrive at set times, prompts from you, and the voices of the group, every day between gatherings.

Who comes back

The measured line shows attendance at the CDC’s National Diabetes Prevention Program, a year of group sessions held weekly and then monthly, across 41,203 people (Cannon and others, 2020). The aim line is ours, drawn through the week 18 figure for people who kept practicing. Meditation practice after a mindfulness course falls the same way (Bondolfi and others, 2010), and so does training at work (Saks and Belcourt, 2006).

The problem with the chat

A group chat holds the plans. A practice holds the group.

Group chats like WhatsApp and Slack are made for plans. They point everyone to the next thing, and they last only as long as the whole group keeps posting. Course platforms hold the lessons in a fixed order. An instrument is built for one purpose: a group keeping its practice alive and learning from each other.

The group chat

Many messages, and nothing to do together.

With an instrument
12:00
record

One practice, on the phone, at its time. Everyone does the same thing, in their own voice.

The solution

A shared practice, sent by you, done together.

Our instruments are grounded in practice.

Every day of deliberate practice runs as a cycle. It starts with a little resistance, moves into flow, and ends with listening back and planning the next pass, with you as the coach.

After the idea of deliberate practice in Peak, by Anders Ericsson and Robert Pool.

How it works

A little effort from you. Then it runs.

Add your people

Put in their numbers, or share one link with the group.

Pick the practices

Choose a few practices and the times they arrive.

Everyone records

Each participant reads the card and presses record.

The group listens

Recordings play on the group's radio. You see who practiced.

Send a prompt any time

Change a practice, move a time, or send a new prompt. It reaches every phone right away.

Built for habit

A practice takes root over many weeks, in the company of others.

We build habits by keeping a practice over many days and weeks. We watch it shift beside other people’s practices, notice what they do and what we do, and find the forms that root us most. In a well-known study at University College London, a new daily habit took 66 days on average to become automatic. The practice times stay the same week after week, and the practices change a little with the season.

The bottom line

Your participants become strong practitioners.

They practice the same things.

They hear each other’s voices every day.

They arrive at every gathering ready.

And in time, they lead the practice the way you did.

It takes a little effort from you at the start. After that the practices carry the group, the app matters a little less each month, and at every gathering whoever shows up can keep the practice going in person.

FAQ

Why is it called SOLOS?

Every instrument runs in one phone app called SOLOS. Everyone practices on their own solo journey, and SOLOS brings many solo journeys together, so a whole group practices side by side.

Does it replace our group chat?

It sits beside it. The chat keeps the plans, and SOLOS keeps the practice.

What do my participants need?

They need a phone. They install the SOLOS app, and you add them by their number or with one link.

How long does a practice take?

You decide. Most practices take between two and ten minutes.

What kinds of practice work?

Any practice you can also do together in person works: reading aloud, walking, telling stories, listening, cooking, singing, and answering a good question.

Who can hear the recordings?

Only the people in your group can hear them.

Can SOLOS connect to my AI tools? I already use AI to set things up.

Yes. SOLOS connects through MCP, so the assistant you already use can write your practices, set their times, and build the schedule for your group.

Can I see the instruments?

Yes. Examples of instruments shows them at work. Press Let’s talk, and we will walk you through the instruments we would make for your group.

Can I use it now?

The instruments are still in development, and we build each one with a facilitator. Leave your email and we will get in touch to hear about your group and what you need.

Practice

Why do practices work?

You already share practices with your groups: a story told aloud, a sitting, a walk, a passage read slowly. A practice works because it is repeated on purpose, at a set time, among people who hear each other. Our instruments are grounded in three kinds of practice.

1

Prescribed practice.

You choose the practice, and you choose the time of day it arrives on each phone.

Put in your participants' numbers and pick a few practices. The instrument sends each card to the whole group at its hour. It can be any practice you teach, as long as people can also do it together when you meet.

2

Deliberate practice.

Everyone does it on purpose, with attention, again and again.

Each day starts with a little resistance and moves into flow. Every practice is kept as a take, so people can listen back and go a little deeper the next day. When you find depth, you can slow down.

After the idea of deliberate practice in Peak, by Anders Ericsson and Robert Pool.

3

Practice in community.

When you meet, you already share something.

Each recording goes to your group's own radio. Participants tune in when they choose, hear each other, and answer. At the next gathering, whoever shows up can keep the practice going in person.

Practice types

Any practice you can also share in person.

Read aloud, speak, listen, respond to a prompt, walk, tell a story, repeat a partner's exercise, or speak their words in your own voice. Each has a few clear steps, and whoever shows up can do the same steps together at the next gathering.

The goal

When you meet, you slow down together.

People arrive having done their homework. They are already grounded in practices they share, so the evening starts deeper and moves slower. The practice moves into the room, the app matters a little less each month, and the group keeps choosing to be together.

Examples

Examples of instruments

An instrument is a combination of modules that lets a practice take place. Instructions say what to do, prompts open each turn, modules hold what participants record and hear, and continuation carries the practice from one day to the next. Each piece below is one module, and the practice comes from the combination.

Every instrument is built with a facilitator, around the practices they already teach. The modules are shown here with the practice you choose.

The Map

Your group’s stories, placed on the map.

Each person puts their stories on a world map, at the places where they happened, and the trail of each story is drawn through the hexagons between them. Others in the group come upon those stories and find their own relationship to them: a place they know, a road they have traveled, a story of their own that answers back. Your group keeps a layer of its own beside the world map, and you choose which stories to share and when.

The world map drawn in lines of blue light, with the cities of the stories named
The Plains

Stories joined by their language.

Every story without a place on the world map gets a plain of its own, with its scenes laid along it. The plains are joined by language: wherever tellings share their words, a way runs between them, so the group moves readily from one person’s story fragments to another’s. Everyone says a thing in their own way, and walking between those fragments shows each person how else a story can be told. The aim is to carry a story off the page and into the voice.

Plains drawn in blue light at different levels, each holding the scenes of one story
The Radio

Your group, on the air.

Recordings stay inside your group and play on its own station. The station chooses what fits the day's practice and what was just recorded, so tuning in feels like hearing the group in the next room. A group can run several stations, with shows that go out at set air times, and one public station that anyone can tune in to. Every class may have a radio, and every student may have a radio of their own if it is so desired.

The Tray

Many tellings, side by side.

The tray encourages participants to record many takes, to speak aloud as much as they can, and to find their words. Each story has its prompt at the head, kept as a reel, and every take fills the next place below it, so the tellings of one story sit side by side and each can be heard beside the last. A tray can be shared with a partner or with the whole group.

A tray of stories, each take kept beside the last, beside the recording block
A Map as Told

Where the tellings meet, and where they part.

This map lays many tellings of one story together as a sand table, including one person’s tellings over weeks and months. Where the takes meet at the same moment of the story, the sand turns in a swirl. Where they share a passage, a labyrinth runs along it. Where they differ, a ridge rises between them, and stones mark the places where the story is set. The group sees how a story changes each time it is recounted, what everyone keeps, and what each person makes their own over time.

The Recording Block

A telling, wound onto a reel.

Every prompt arrives as a reel. Your participants record at the cast block, and the tape winds from the block onto the reel as they speak. Each telling is transcribed, so the group can read a take as well as hear it, and pictures, drawings and other media can be attached to it. The recording is the basic element of every instrument: the instruments are primarily oral, and they also receive visualizations.

The cast recording block beside three prompt reels
Speechform

The shape of what is said, grown into a picture.

Speechform listens to how something is said and grows an image from it as the speaker goes. A story lays down a path and forks a new way for each idea, thinking aloud grows one stalk whose branches are its ideas, and a poem opens in petals. A lesson stacks stone on stone, a conversation comes in like the tide, and a song moves in waves.

When the speaker comes back to an idea, its branch grows again, so a long telling leaves a picture of its own shape. The picture is made of shapes alone. Beside a take, it shows at a glance how a telling moved, and the group can see the shape of each other’s practice as well as hear it.

The Board

The whole day at a glance.

The Board lays out a day’s activities as cups, set in pockets that gather by the time of day and radiate from the center. Every take recorded that day rests in its cup as a gold reel, and a small projector names each one. A participant sees the shape of their day, and a facilitator sees the group’s.

The Board: cups radiating from a center, a reel resting in each one done
Microfilm and Tape

Every word, kept on film.

The words of every take are kept on film inside a black stone cube, each with its reel of tape beside it. Look through the cube’s lens to read a telling, and narrow the film by activity, word, day or mark to find the takes you need.

A grid of microfilm cubes, each holding the words of one take
The Storehouse

A story is a storehouse.

A storehouse receives things, holds them, and gives them out again. A story works the same way. When you listen to one, you walk through a storehouse, seeing what it holds and choosing what you would like to collect and leave with, and you may find something different every time you hear it.

The Storehouse receives and holds every take as a reel, in a building of many rooms: the High Bay, the Vault, the Lean Rack, the Round House and the Mixed Room. Find a recording by its words, collect a few in a box, and send them to the map or onto a radio show.

The Storehouse drawn in blue light: tall racks of shelves holding reels
How it works

How the instruments reach your group.

Behind every instrument is a simple routine. You write the practices, they arrive through the day, everyone records, and the group hears each other.

Add your people

Put in their numbers, or share one link with the group.

Pick the practices

Choose a few practices and the times they arrive.

Everyone records

Each participant reads the card and presses record.

The group listens

Recordings play on the group's radio. You see who practiced.

Send a prompt any time

Change a practice, move a time, or send a new prompt. It reaches every phone right away.

Prescribed practice

Your practices are dealt to participants each day.

You write a few cards and choose the time of day each one arrives. The whole group receives the same card at once, and you see who has practiced.

A sundial of eight petals, drawn in blue light
The Sundial and the app

A day of practice, told by the sun.

Each participant’s day lies on a sundial of eight petals. Its shadow moves as the real sun does, and the day’s practices sit along it from morning to night. Each one lights as the shadow reaches it and stays marked once it is done. The sundial encourages regularity, so practice becomes part of how the whole day is lived.

Each participant opens the app to their sundial. They do each practice aloud, the take is kept as a reel, and the group’s takes arrive beside it. It works like a calendar, not a feed. Your practices arrive through the day, and your group is on the other end.

The day

Each participant's day of practice, through the seasons.

SOLOS lays each day out as a clock of practice times. Daylight grows and shrinks with the seasons, and practice times move with sunrise and sunset. Practices can change from day to day, differ for each person, or rotate between participants.

Depth

Watch the group go deeper, month after month.

Every take is kept, and a circle of twenty records hundreds of them a week. One hour of your own practice comes with many more hours of hearing each other practice.

Aaron Goldstein
About

Aaron Goldstein

Founder and learning engineer

My work is sequencing good practices that get people where they want to go in life. I design them to be done aloud, at regular times, in the company of others.

Where it began

A book filled to the brim with meditation exercises.

I remember opening a book in the library that was filled to the brim with meditation exercises. I read each one with vigor. Every exercise was meant to be spoken aloud, so I sat down and spoke them all aloud to myself. I came to see that they could only make sense if somebody read them aloud to me, in the correct cadence, someone who knew something about the expression each exercise carried. The book said as much. You have to do these regularly to understand them. You have to repeat them. And there is no limit to any one exercise: you can pick one and do it for a year.

I closed that book, and I thought about it regularly for many years. Now I understand it.

All my life I have attended school, formal and informal practices, workshops, retreats and trainings, always with the same curiosity. What can I take from this and practice myself? What can a group take from this class and practice together? What are the activities, exercises and practices that we can repeat for continuous deepening? These questions became how I gauged whether a class or course could succeed.

Once I understood what success meant to me, I went looking for it. I analyzed the entire EdTech industry for companies that offer it. I visited hundreds of classrooms to learn how practices live in traditional education. I studied learning engineering to better assess the qualities of learning I was seeking. And I gravitated to many forms of oral learning, running experiments to see how practice-based learning shapes the lives of practitioners on their journey.

The experiments

I tried each practice on myself first.

Since 2020 I have taken up one practice after another and lived with it until it taught me something. Some lasted a single day, like recording an album in one session. Others ran for years, like guiding tours through Boston.

This year the experiments turned toward other people. I joined a circle of deep listening on Sunday mornings, I train every day with a teacher, and I facilitate groups of my own.

What I found

How do you keep a community together, practicing its practices?

I found patterns that worked in these settings in the moment and clearly made for peak learning experiences. I also found a question people have faced since the dawn of modernity, and some communities form for just this purpose. People dedicated to Mysore Ashtanga yoga show up at their shala early in the morning, before everyone else has woken. Dream spelunkers write down their dream as soon as they wake. Those who follow The Artist’s Way wake up and write for thirty minutes. Musicians keep their riyaz, an hour of practice every day. Tai Chi practitioners move through their form every day.

What unites these practices is that they are solo journeys. They happen daily, at set times that move with the seasons, and community guides them.

Four parts

Every practice that lasts has four parts.

Looking closely, I found that each of these communities holds together in the same four parts.

  1. Each person learns or practices something on their own.
  2. Each person teaches something to a peer.
  3. A peer teaches something to them.
  4. A facilitator teaches something to them.

These are deeply spiritual matters. They require community, coming together, and people willing to take responsibility as facilitator, host or speaker, even temporarily or in a round robin. Each practice keeps the four parts in a rhythm of its own across a month.

Many practices

A day of practices guides a life.

The other quality I learned about is that people who succeed have a day-long set of practices that guide their lives. It takes more than one practice. The question I ask in my work is this one.

How can many practices, primarily oral ones, set at regular times through the day, lead to a well-rounded life?

Intact systems

Utopia, collective regulation, and the fabric of a culture.

Alongside this work I study utopia and collective regulation. The study grew out of educational change, which led me to look for complete and intact systems that are well regulated: places where a culture’s practices hold its people together over whole lives. What I saw in common across them is what this essay describes: people practicing alone, teaching one another, and learning from those who carry the tradition, at set times, again and again.

Five works are my main sources for that study. Each one is a lens on the fabric a culture has to tie it together, and I have read all five aloud onto my radio station.

  • The 1001 Arabian NightsA vast collection of oral storytelling, where cliffhangers, retellings and the endless weaving of tales show the dramatic power of voice itself. When people tell stories prolifically, the telling makes social, temporal and cultural fabric.
  • The Glass Bead Game, Hermann HesseThough a work of satire, it gave me a vision of how stories, symbols and disciplines might interweave in play, held by a whole order devoted to the game.
  • The Spell of the Sensuous, David AbramIt reminds us that speech itself is ecological, and that language arose in reciprocity with wind, water, birds, forests and the more-than-human world.
  • Learning in Depth, Kieran EganIt shows how knowledge deepens through cycles of return, as students revisit a topic over years and move from wonder to reflection.
  • Deschooling Society, Ivan IllichIt offers a vision of tools that help communities act together simply, generatively and communally, and of learning webs that join each person to things, skills, peers and elders.
Repetition

We learn the most from what we repeat.

I have gone in many directions to understand what kinds of people and what kinds of practices are like this in the world. The ones where you learn the most come from repeating activities, exercises or practices, whether they are recreational, in community, professional or solo.

These lead us to the deepest knowledge. Ask someone who truly knows something, and you will find the knowing lives in their routine, because they have practiced it so many times that it has become ingrained. These are the able people I have met. I understand it from being around them and from practicing myself, and so I share it with the world.

If I were asked what I would do if I could do only one thing for the rest of my life, it would be to take my violin out of its case, play, and put it back. Every repetition is a repetition, and yet each one must be different.

What I build

Practices, sequenced for anyone, at any hour.

So the question became how to sequence practices for the people who need them, asynchronously, at the times when a community is apart or still forming. Now I have an application that sequences all of these practices for anybody to have.

Analogous forms of real activities live in these instruments. They support those activities, serve as analogies for them, and join people together in practice who would otherwise practice alone, fulfilling Illich’s vision. Then people get together, and perhaps they stay together for some time.

My goal in designing these activities is to process material immediately, so it can keep being processed into forms that ask for more and more novel interaction. Each one opens more cycles of creation and analysis, on and on. Together they make a visual language for oral workflows.

The facilitator

Replicate something good you learned, and share it.

That is what all of this has in common: replicating a form I learned. It always takes repetition, commitment and showing up to practice. That is the way. I learned something valuable, and as a subject matter expert who has gone down a pathway, I know I can share that pathway in practice form. That is the primary way to learn.

My learning engineering background is here for the people who want their expression truly shared with others, so that those others become strong practitioners. Facilitators, in their lives, have one goal: to replicate something good they learned and share it. That is what we do. I believe that is the goal of being a facilitator.

As a musician and storyteller, and as one who facilitates group jams and community storytelling, I invite you to try out my offerings.

Let's talk

Leading a practice? Let's talk.

We are building these instruments with the people who need them. If you lead a practice and want it to keep going between gatherings, leave your email. We would like to hear about your group.

  • Your participants share a practice between every gathering.
  • You hear how everyone is doing without keeping a chat alive.
  • More people show up, and they arrive ready to slow down.